Winning Always Wins. Will Integrity Place, or Even Show?


Thirty useless horses at a California monitor. Federal indictments accusing more than two dozen trainers and veterinarians from Florida to New York of doping their animals. All prior to now two and a half years.

Is there something the game of thoroughbred racing holds sacred?

On Sunday, we discovered: the Kentucky Derby.

Almost as quickly as Bob Baffert introduced that his colt Medina Spirit had failed a drug check after profitable the 147th operating of America’s best race, officers of Churchill Downs made it clear that if a second pattern confirmed the presence of betamethasone, a corticosteroid injected into joints to scale back ache and swelling, the colt could be disqualified and Mandaloun, the runner-up, could be declared the winner.

Apparently, Churchill Downs treasures the Derby’s standing sufficient to return down onerous on rule breakers, even one who has stood within the winner’s circle seven instances.

“I would like to be optimistic about our sport but today we are an embarrassment,” tweeted Graham Motion, who educated the 2011 Derby winner, Animal Kingdom. “Perhaps we have to hit rock bottom before things get better but we only have ourselves and the leaders of our sport to blame. For anyone that loves the sport as much as I do it’s a sad day.”

While the world waits for the second check end result, anticipated within the coming weeks, the game is on to Baltimore for the Preakness Stakes, the place Medina Spirit will attempt to win the second leg of the Triple Crown and one other Baffert horse, Concert Tour, will attempt to beat him.

No one ought to blame Medina Spirit for this mess. He did what horses are presupposed to do — run quick.

In truth, really feel sorry for him and his rider, John Velazquez, whose fourth Derby victory could be erased from the historical past books. Then once more, Velazquez can be astride Medina Spirit on Saturday, with one other likelihood to win.

Only in a sport with no central authority and with haphazardly enforced guidelines may a deal be brokered just like the one Baffert made with the homeowners of Pimlico Race Course, the host of the Preakness: Medina Spirit can run if he assessments clear on a number of blood samples and his veterinarian data are discovered to be so as.

Baffert, the Hall of Fame coach, declared he wouldn’t be in Baltimore as a result of he didn’t wish to be a distraction. Or so he mentioned.

Of course, he has mentioned fairly just a few issues. Over a interval of 72 hours, the coach first insisted that there was no approach Medina Spirit had examined optimistic, then blamed cancel tradition, mysterious contamination and racing officers out to get him, and eventually mentioned, Oh yeah, we gave him the drug, but we didn’t know we were doing it.

On Tuesday, Baffert acknowledged treating Medina Spirit for a rash by utilizing an antifungal ointment known as Otomax, which — to Baffert’s professed shock — contained betamethasone.

The failed check and Baffert’s evolving explanations have shocked informal followers, offered punch traces to hosts of late evening speak exhibits and handed extra ammunition to animal rights activists who need the game shut down altogether.

“Look at the damage this has done to our sport,” mentioned Arthur Hancock III, a fourth-generation horse breeder. “It’s hung a dark cloud over horse racing and a dark cloud over Kentucky.”

For greater than 30 years, the Hancock household was amongst a core of breeders and homeowners who pushed the game to crack down on a tradition of doping that was enabled by lax regulation. One invoice after one other didn’t get out of Congress, due to reliably constant opposition — from horse trainers, whom the payments focused, and from racetracks that didn’t need the headache of federal regulation.

So what’s the fuss over somewhat remedy? A horse on painkillers might run all-out on an injured leg as a result of it doesn’t really feel the injury. When horses break down, there may be often no bringing them again. In Southern California, 30 horses at Santa Anita Park had to be euthanized over a six-month interval beginning in December 2018, inflaming animal rights activists and placing the game within the cross-hairs of regulation enforcement.

To say nothing of the danger to the jockeys, who go down when their mounts do.

Last 12 months, lastly, Congress handed the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Act, which requires a board overseen by the Federal Trade Commission to put in writing guidelines and penalties to be enforced by the United States Anti-Doping Agency. The company, which regulates Olympians and different elite athletes within the United States, revealed the cyclist Lance Armstrong’s cheating and issued him a lifetime suspension in 2012. The regulation will take impact July 1, 2022.

If the antidoping program have been in place now, this complete circus might have been prevented.

The testing labs would have met world-class requirements, would have been quick and environment friendly — no ready weeks for a second check end result, as we are going to with Medina Spirit — and would have meted out harder penalties, particularly for ache remedy. Deterrents like rigorous and constant out-of-competition testing might need stored Medina Spirit out of the Derby beginning gate or ensured that he entered it clear. And Baffert, stained by 4 different optimistic drug assessments racked up in somewhat greater than a 12 months, could be dealing with a 180-day suspension, in accordance with the baseline guidelines.

On the morning after Medina Spirit gained the Derby, nicely earlier than the optimistic check was revealed, Amanda Simmons Luby composed a tweet thread that was as prescient because the suspicions that impressed it are heartbreaking. Luby fell in love with horse racing as somewhat lady studying Walter Farley’s series of “Black Stallion” books. As a younger lady, she entered the thoroughbred trade, working within the stables of the Hall of Fame coach D. Wayne Lukas, breaking in yearlings in Ireland and dealing at a stallion station in central Kentucky.

She finally went to regulation faculty and labored as an legal professional, however she has returned to the game as a breeder. A really small breeder — she has two mares. Medina Spirit was bred by a girl with a equally modest operation and bought as a yearling for less than $1,000. His present proprietor, Amr Zedan of Saudi Arabia, received him for a track, $35,000. But Luby couldn’t get excited by the colt’s victory.

“Wouldn’t it be nice to have a Derby winner where the general public is able to celebrate the victory without reservation?” her tweet thread began.

Her unease was with Baffert, who she acknowledges is personable and maybe the best coach of all time — with a file seven Derby titles and two Triple Crowns. But she couldn’t get previous his drug violations — 30 of them.

“I call it the Lance Armstrong effect, where there’s reason to question the wins,” she advised me on the cellphone. “We sincerely hope our champions we put on this pedestal did not get there by illicit means. I’m afraid the Lance Armstrongs permeate our industry.”

And if that’s true?

Seven days earlier than the general public knew that Medina Spirit had flunked a drug check, Luby knew how excessive the stakes have been.

“If this industry has any hope of surviving, the masses (both in & out of the sport) have to believe the playing field is fair,” she wrote on Twitter beneath the deal with Welbourne Stud, the identify of her breeding enterprise. “A good portion of us have grave concerns that it is not. Without a well-grounded sense of fairness, why spend another dime on the sport?”

For too lengthy, ideas and good intentions have completed a distant second to profitable. Let’s hope it’s not too late to flip that equation.





Source link