Are Tech’s Wealthiest Men Worth Their Pay?


This article is a part of the On Tech newsletter. You can sign up here to obtain it weekdays.

Apple paid its chief government, Tim Cook, $1.four billion in complete since 2007. Oracle’s chairman, Larry Ellison, racked up inventory and money valued at practically $1.9 billion over the identical interval. And Mark Zuckerberg has pulled in $5.7 billion from Facebook for the reason that firm went public in 2012.

These are among the many billion-dollar males of the know-how business. The cumulative paychecks of a half dozen executives topped $13.2 billion, in response to a brand new evaluation of the previous 15 years. Those are years during which tech corporations grow to be highly effective forces within the financial system, our lives and world affairs. The temper about know-how has soured extra not too long ago, however the tech bosses’ paychecks principally remained unscathed.

The New York Times revealed on Friday an analysis of the most highly paid chief executives of America’s publicly traded corporations in 2020. During the pandemic, the executives acquired a few of the richest pay packages ever, my colleague Peter Eavis reported.

To get an image of what corporations paid their bosses over an extended time period, the manager compensation consulting agency Equilar ranked the 10 executives with essentially the most cumulative complete pay, going way back to 2006 when there was a change in company compensation disclosures. Tech bosses took six of these 10 spots, largely due to the worth of inventory that their corporations gave them.

The billion-dollar-plus paychecks of a handful of males — and sure, they’re all males — deliver up an enormous and unanswerable query: How do we all know in the event that they’re well worth the cash?

Baseball stat geeks learn about a measure referred to as wins above replacement, which tries to quantify the worth of a participant by estimating what number of extra or fewer wins a staff has with him in contrast with a alternative who may be cheaper. Even within the tech business, which obsesses over information, there may be little try to use a wins above alternative stat for the nook workplace.

Maybe a hypothetical alternative chief of Alphabet would do a greater job than Sundar Pichai, and for lower than the $1.1 billion in inventory and different compensation that Google’s mum or dad firm has paid him since 2015, in response to the Equilar evaluation. Boards of administrators don’t sometimes attempt to discover out. Chief executives are paid what they’re paid.

Let me dig deeper into a few the C.E.O. pay figures. Calculating what company chiefs are “paid” is an advanced and contentious train. In some instances, the tech bosses’ compensation is even bigger than the mind-boggling numbers initially prompt.

When Cook took over for Steve Jobs in 2011 as Apple’s chief government, the corporate pledged to offer him as many as 28 million shares, after adjusting for inventory splits, over the subsequent decade. Back then, Cook topped The Times’s annual rating of highest paid C.E.O.s, based mostly largely on the potentially $376 million value of that stock. One skilled referred to as Cook’s inventory award “historic to such a degree that it skews the numbers.”

But Cook would take dwelling all of the shares provided that he caught round for 10 years and if the corporate’s inventory worth rose quicker than that of most different giant corporations. So what’s going to occur? Cook is prone to gather all or practically all the shares, with a closing batch due in August. Those shares, by one calculation, at the moment are value $3.5 billion, or practically 10 instances that “historic” quantity a decade in the past.

Companies sometimes justify top-dollar government paychecks by saying that the bosses are irreplaceable and that they solely get wealthy when shareholders do, as a result of they’re paid largely in inventory. Cook’s pockets has gotten fatter since 2011 from Apple’s climbing inventory worth, proper alongside anybody who occurred to purchase Apple inventory.

But once more, it’s laborious to evaluate how a lot of Apple’s monetary or inventory efficiency is Cook’s doing. Maybe you’ll do 80 p.c in addition to Cook at a fraction of the fee.

Apple doesn’t disclose the $3.5 billion determine straight. I tallied it from Apple’s annual statements to shareholders. Equilar calculated that Cook’s cumulative compensation since 2007, when he was Apple’s chief working officer, is $1.four billion. Equilar’s determine assessed the worth of Cook’s inventory in every year that it was launched to him, not the present worth of these shares. Like I stated, there are lots of methods to slice and cube C.E.O. pay.

The figures might sound mild years (or a handful of zeros) away from most individuals’s monetary conditions, however additionally they have a heartening message for anybody who feels clueless about cash.

Zuckerberg topped the Equilar rating of longer-term C.E.O. pay, virtually totally from inventory choices on 120 million shares that Facebook handed him shortly after the corporate was based. Zuckerberg offered about one-third of these shares for $2.Three billion greater than a yr after Facebook went public. If he’d held onto these shares as an alternative, they’d be value practically $14 billion now.

But don’t unfastened sleep worrying about Zuckerberg’s poorly timed inventory sale. He’s nonetheless worth $124 billion.



  • About that discounted web service … Emergency authorities funds are supposed to assist lower-income Americans scale back their month-to-month web payments by as much as $50. The information website Protocol discovered that even a small discrepancy — akin to an tackle entered “Street” as an alternative of “St.” — have been causing some internet companies to block eligible people. (The Washington Post wrote final month about different shenanigans on this web low cost program.)

  • Break out the soldering irons! Vice News stories that New York could also be poised to grow to be the primary U.S. state to move a legislation that should make it easier and cheaper to repair your electronics and different stuff. Some product makers, together with Apple and John Deere, have lobbied in opposition to these “right to repair” laws that might require them to offer folks and fix-it retailers entry to data manuals, instruments and components as an alternative of relying solely on licensed restore suppliers.

  • How about “The Crown” crowns? To make more money, Netflix opened a web-based retailer for merchandise related to the company and its shows, together with “Lupin” throw pillows and Netflix-brand boxer shorts, my colleagues John Koblin and Sapna Maheshwari report.

Here is a dwell video feed to look at the snorting, waddling antics of elephant seals on a California seashore. (This was among the many entertainment recommendations from my colleague Amanda Hess.)


We wish to hear from you. Tell us what you consider this article and what else you’d like us to discover. You can attain us at ontech@nytimes.com.

If you don’t already get this article in your inbox, please sign up here. You may learn past On Tech columns.



Source link